Saturday, January 03, 2009

High Concept/Alan Partridge

Idea for a television show, possibly an "ER" spinoff. ER: The Finance Department. Would revolve around a debt collector working for an American hospital, who has a limited amount of discretion to waive bills in circumstances of true hardship. Every week, he investigages the circumstances of a poor or middle-class American family with a crippling medical expense, deciding to what extent they're truly morally responsible for their own misfortune, or what luxury items in their house he believes they could do without; he could have a catchy thumbs-up/thumbs-down plus catchphrase to form the denouement of every episode. Would sell brilliantly in America, where everyone would enjoy vicariously judging distinctions between the deserving and feckless poor (and would make for good water-cooler discussions later, as people debated whether the Collector was right or not, plus any time ratings began to sag you could chuck in The Abortion Episode). Would also sell well internationally, as everyone around the world would like to gawk at the amazingly dysfunctional American health insurance system (this concept proven by Michael Moore's "Sicko"). Only drawback would be that it kind of times out if USA has meaningful healthcare reform, but I hardly think that's an obstacle to a long and successful run.

Update: For some reason I see Craig Ferguson in the title role.

It's horrifyingly likely I'll be doing more of these during 2009. Happy New Year to my dwindling band of readers.

24 comments:

  1. It was an eye-opener watching my American in-laws having to deal with a family medical emergency at 10pm on Christmas day.

    The refusal of the paramedics to even give a recommendation on whether my schizophrenic uncle-in-law (found on his bedroom floor with a gangrenous toe) should be taken to hospital or not (for fear of liability suits), followed by discussions about $1,000 ambulance bills should he be taken to the wrong (but local) hospital and then later need moving to the VA hospital fifty miles down the road for actual treatment.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've been looking (unsuccessfully) for a BBC online story I read earlier in the year about a chap employed by a West London NHS trust to decide whether or not asylum seekers should be charged for their treatment, i.e. whether or not they were "bogus". I reckon my fly-on-the-wall series following this guy would top our host's drama in the ratings. (My working title is The Biggest Cunt in West London).

    ReplyDelete
  3. Here?

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7367806.stm

    ReplyDelete
  4. That's good, and gives me an idea for another show: Triage. It's ER: The Finance Department meets M.A.S.H., but in Iraq. Tag line: "You go to war with the army you have."

    ReplyDelete
  5. Matthew: yes, that's the chap. I was thinking of Jon Gaunt to do the voiceover.

    ReplyDelete
  6. What is this dwindling band of readers? You will always have at least one, me, coming in for a view everyonce in a while. Your comments, good ideas don't need lies to sell, at the start of the current unpleasantness in Iraq was enough for me to know you were a go to guy.
    Best to you and the other readers.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I mean that the readership will dwindle even more if (that is to say, when) I keep cranking out "Idea for a sitcom" content.

    I'm currently toying with "Nassim Nicholas Taleb's Flying Circus", in which he gives a sort of Simon Schama/Niall Ferguson/JJ Bronowski tour of his ideas on economics, philosophy and aesthetics. But all the time, large feet suddenly stamp on his head, the camera pans across to reveal a naked organist, etc. Every time he says "but nobody can forecast ...", a bunch of red-garbed Spanish inquisitors leap out from behind some scenery. I'm seeing Ricky Gervais in the title role.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Second the Taleb idea.

    You could throw in a drinking game for the viewers as well - everytime he says 'nobody can forecast', the Spanish Inquisition shit could happen AND viewers could be encouraged to drink a shot of some good, strong and nourishing alcoholic beverage. Last one left standing can text into the show - following which certain added benefits are received.

    This kind of thing builds loyalty to the show and it could get sponsorship from the booze companies as well.

    ReplyDelete
  9. "For some reason I see Craig Ferguson in the title role."

    You mean, playing the Finance Department? That would take quite a performance.

    Sorry, couldn't resist.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This crack is a bit of a laugh for a while, but it's fundamentally a mug's game/down-the-pub running gag that is unworthy of serious consideration.

    Real producers are doing this sort of game and worse *for a living* and are better at it than you. And they get their stuff broadcast, often before the watershed. You can't beat 'em.

    (Unless you are Charlie Brooker. God, at least I hope the real producers can't outdo him.)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I think a better Taleb vehicle would be Smug Idol. Get him, Malcolm Gladwell, Oliver Kamm, etc. together. Each week, they would be given a trite truism to dress up in their own unique style, and the voting audience gets to vote one out. I suggest that week one be 'Ne'er cast a clout till May is out'.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Oddly enough my next idea for a sitcom was going to be a sort of dark version of "The Larry Sanders Show", but based round a panel discussion show where the panel consisted of Taleb, Bernard-Henri Levy, David Starkey, etc. The central character (Nicholas Lyndhurst?) would be the researcher responsible for arranging other guests to appear and debate with them, and the plot arc would revolve around his inevitable descent into suicidal depression and alcoholism. Haven't got a title yet though.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The one American medical show of recent years where the issue of cost and insurance coverage has featured on a fairly regular basis?

    Scrubs.

    There was one episode where the doctors sneaked in poor buggers for treatment by sticking the line-items onto the bills of the fully-covered and recently-departed.

    Anyway, given the current output in the slough that is American television between Thanksgiving and late January, I could see Extreme Makeover: Medical Bill Edition getting picked up.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Didn't J.G. Ballard have "poor people beg for money" as one of the items in a predicted TV schedule for 2000?

    ReplyDelete
  15. It appears that ABC already made D2's programme, albeit in a way that smooths over the issue of cost.

    And on cue, the first episode of Scrubs in its new network home features Courteney Cox as the incoming head of medicine, who'll stabilise and release people with shitty insurance, while ordering a bucketload of unnecessary tests on someone who comes in with "shortness of breath" but has primo coverage.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Right, we now have the makings of an excellent game for 2009 - I'll come up with a suitably Partridge-like and repulsive idea, and you lot have to go out and find when it was actually made.

    Nick makes a very good point about Scrubs - it's possibly the most left-wing show on American television.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Well, the foundation for any reality show seems to be televised backbiting and humiliation - should give plenty of scope.

    I think your original idea could be improved by having two needy families per episode, meaning that each one has to argue not only why they should get their bills paid but why the other lot shouldn't.

    For added ratings, you could bring in the Culture Wars - have a Northern versus a Southern family, evangelical Christians v. normal Christians, black v. white...

    ReplyDelete
  18. Are you familiar with Charlie Brooker's TV Go Home? In the form of a page of the Radio Times, it previewed ever more horrible and unlikely television programmes. It has since been mined by comedy writers (e.g. Nathan Barley) and, apparently, by serious television executives. Wanking for Coins appeared in the 1999-04-02 edition of TV Go Home; eight years later Brooker observed that it had effectively been commissioned by ITV under the title Fortune: Million Pound Giveaway.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Charlie Brooker actually co-wrote Nathan Barley (which had been a regular feature in TVGoHome, under the more descriptive title of Cunt), so that's scarcely 'mining'.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Wanking for Coins appeared in the 1999-04-02 edition of TV Go Home; eight years later Brooker observed that it had effectively been commissioned by ITV under the title Fortune: Million Pound Giveaway.

    And here is the cheap version for children's TV.

    ReplyDelete
  21. You can mine your old material for ideas, but it's still mining.

    ReplyDelete