Thursday, May 17, 2012

Death of a man who could play in time

It's in lousy taste and more than a little arseholish, I know, but I wouldn't be true to myself if I didn't take advantage of the short gap between deaths to mention that an awful lot of these "iconic, genius" figures who are currently dying were actually total journeymen who held down roles competently in mid-table entertainment outfits.  I mean, Levon Helm?  Yes, important role on two or three (and clsoer to two than three) records that solidly fill out the middle of everyone's top 200.  But if you had said "of course, Levon Helm is one of the towering figures of popular music in the twentieth century" three months ago, people would have looked at you funny.  Similarly, Donald "Duck" Dunn was a good bass player and wrote an instructional book which I still use and like, but I would very much invite any of the people who referred to his "unique and characteristic groove" to do a blind listening test between MGs records which he did and didn't play on.

It's the first-of-the-gang-to-die syndrome again, as it was with Hitchens.  When people wax elegiac about these figures, they're basically writing about their own impending death.  Actuarially, the bulge in mortality of sixties dudes which started with my dad and will presumably end with Paul McCartney (married, vegetarian diet, keeps active - the annuity industry is going to get hosed on that one) is going to peak over the next four or five years, so at some point soon we are going to be having a new iconic figure who defined our childhood more or less every week.

Update: I of course bloody knew that within a minute of me putting that up, another beloved-but-forgotten-about entertainer would die, making me look callous.  Donna Summer.

10 comments:

  1. I don't mind if people would have looked at me funny, but I'd have said it re Levon Helm well in advance. The Band really were important and he was one of the key figures in it, not just as a drummer either. Lots of stuff just wouldn't have happened without Music from the Big Pink. (Americana, but arguably a lot of British Folk Rock given the way the record made Fairport change direction. Dunn? Well you may have a point. But let me say *in advance* that I'd do the "seminal figure" thing re Steve Cropper.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Incidentally, LH was hardly the first of the gang to die ... he's the third, since Danko and Manuel are already long gone. All members of the 3rd most important band in rock history (after the Beatles and the Stones) - at least, such is my perverse opinion, which has the consequence that only 1 member of the 3 most important bands (LH) was American.

    ReplyDelete
  3. the 3rd most important band in rock history (after the Beatles and the Stones)

    I think it's more that they were the third most attuned to your own taste ... at the very least, you'll have a tough time making the case in the week when the next Beach Boy pegs out. I see The Band as pretty quintessentially mid-table and think that almost exactly the same things would have happened in a slightly different way (you had Buffalo Springfield ploughing a quite similar furrow frex). But I doubt it's a productive argument - I can see that the case could be made, but a hell of a lot more stuff wouldn't have happened without Deep Purple (oh god, I can just see the tributes and reappraisals on that one ...).

    Of course you're right about Helm not being the first, but he was the first to die of a condition recognisable as "basically old age". Which is what I was trying to get at with first-of-the-gang-to-die syndrome - if you're not yourself a drug addict or alcoholic, you're not really going to see the death of Jimi Hendrix etc as something that might have happened to you. It's when people start going for things that could happen tomorrow to the editor of the music section that he starts imbuing them with a significance that he really didn't feel at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  4. a hell of a lot more stuff wouldn't have happened without Deep Purple

    Now that's trolling! I tip my hat sir.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I didn't say good stuff, but it happened, and with a healthy lifestyle and if I cut down on the booze and eat more vegetables, I definitely look forward to hearing that Ian Gillan was an incredibly seminal figure ...

    ReplyDelete
  6. THUMP, THUMP, THUMP,
    Another one bites the dust
    And another one gone, and another one gone
    Another one bites the dust ....

    ReplyDelete
  7. Shouldn't you guys be doing this behind the scenes over @ CT?

    Anyway, I agree with BB about rankings. I suspect some deadheads would have some strong words (if they could only enunciate them) with you. Also, where the do you classify soloists like Elvis or Dylan, whom I heard Arlo describe as having written the sound track for the '60s? I know CB wrote "bands", but this implicitly downplays the importance of the Beatles and Stones.[1]

    [1] Something about race seems to be lurking here, no?

    ReplyDelete
  8. And now Robin Gibb...

    Weekly you say; They're dropping day by day.

    ReplyDelete
  9. It's only going to accelerate. We had a discussion on Twitter about this and the conclusion was that the broadcasters (who only have a finite amount of time to dedicate to tributes) are going to work on a first-past-the-post system - the most famous person who dies on any given day gets the encomia, and anyone less famous dying on the same day gets the Lee Brilleaux treatment.

    ReplyDelete