- Congestion "pricing"? Road "pricing"? These are taxes, folks; flat rate excise duties payable on the act of driving a car across a line. There is no market in permissions to use a road; there isn't even any variability of the "price" with demand, although there are nebulous proposals to introduce it at some unspecified point in the future on the basis of something not unlike Soviet central planning. I think I will put forward proposals for "inheritance pricing", "capital gains pricing" and "a progressive rate of income pricing" and see if I can get such breathless support for them from the Wall Street Journal, Economist, etc.
- Just a little bit of help for any New Yorker fact-checkers out there looking for the source of a quotation commonly attributed to Keynes and regularly in the financial press:
"The market can stay irrational for longer than you can stay solvent".
It doesn't appear anywhere in any of Keynes' work to the best of anyone's knowledge. The first published appearance that I've been able to find is in "The Money Game" by George Goodman (writing as "Adam Smith"), who attributes it to Keynes. When quoted in this form, Goodman is almost certainly the original source.
However, the quote is probably not bogus or apocryphal. When this came up on the PEN-L mailing list, we ended up concluding that the original source was almost certainly Joan Robinson, and that therefore Keynes probably made this remark at seminars at Cambridge in the 30s; there are a number of Keynes quotes where the trail ends up with Robinson in this way. - And here is my attempt to branch out into the Gina Ford market with a top child-rearing tip; while a real gun is obviously a much more dangerous weapon than a real sword, a toy gun cannot be used to hit other kids round the head with, although a toy sword can.
that's d-squared with a hyphen, dammit.
Like Brad Delong's site, but with more liberal use of the F-word and less about the New York Times.
Tuesday, May 08, 2007
Bits and pieces
Re congestion charging: Ssh. If it's a tax, the US embassy doesn't have to pay it.
ReplyDeleteIs a bridge toll a tax? It looks economically the same whether it's levied by a private firm (or DBO) or by a government.
It seems to me you can hit someone over the head with pretty much anything. With a toy gun, you just have to be a bit closer.
ReplyDeleteYeah. Tell you what though, as I work in a children's bookshop I could maybe experiment a little on the customers and report back?
ReplyDeleteTalking of untraceable quotes, I don't suppose anybody can confirm whether or not Gramsci actually said "common sense is the day-to-day ideology of the bourgeoisie"?
Years ago I went to dine at King's Cambridge. The table talk was littered with "As Maynard used to say...". The old boy had been a notable conversationalist. So no mystery, I suspect.
ReplyDeleteWell, yes. What's the difference between a price and a tax anyway? If I cross a state-owned bridge I have to pay £2 (for example). If I buy a packet of cigarettes I have to pay money to the government. If I send off for a government-produced document like the Highway Code, I have to pay as well. Which of these payments is tax and which is a price?
ReplyDeleteTax, tax and provision of a service (unless the government also charges VAT on Highway Codes).
ReplyDelete